M33, M45 and C/2022 E3 dusk to dawn

Astrophotography: share your photos & discuss techniques
User avatar
Pete
Astro Day Coordinator
Posts: 4003
Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2003 9:03 pm

M33, M45 and C/2022 E3 dusk to dawn

Unread post by Pete »

Thursday, 19 Jan 2023

Looks like a break in the weather. Shifted the 2600 from the 14” to the 102mm (with LP filter), and was out at 17:00 starting the focus/flats/dark flats routine. Focus was done using a Bahtinov mask. Several objectives tonight including obtaining images so that the refractor performance can be compared to the same objects run last year with the Hyperstar, viewing the ISS and then capture of comet C/2002 E3 ZTF. The sky’s “winter transparent” with a 10mph breeze and temperature in the low 40s.

M33 I initially started imaging with 1 minute exposure to avoid burning out the core, but gave up on that after a bit and shifted to 3 minutes.
M33 stretched arcsinh s.jpg
M33 stretched arcsinh s.jpg (2.38 MiB) Viewed 965 times
Messier 33 – the Triangulum Galaxy
18:03 – 22:01 hrs EST, 19 Jan 2023
80 X 3 min, unbinned, 200 gain, -20° cooling, 1 Hz guiding
Explore Scientific 102mm triplet with Optolong LP-P filter and ASI 2600MC-P camera

For comparison, here’s the 1 Nov 2021 Hyperstar image:
M33 8x11.jpg
M33 8x11.jpg (1.58 MiB) Viewed 965 times
Hyperstar 31 X 3 min, 1X, -20C, 200 gain, 5 sec guiding

The hour and 33 minute Hyperstar image shows a tad more detail that the 4-hour refractor image. Very much brighter.

The ISS had a decent pass: 36° above the NW horizon. Parked myself in a chair in a dark section of the back yard at 18:45. Always amazed with an ISS pass and this one didn’t disappoint. -2.5 magnitude.

Upon completion of M33 the night is still perfect for stargazing. The wind’s died completely.

All the wonders of the winter sky are there before me, but the 2nd object must be quick as I’d like to catch some sleep before climbing out of bed in the wee hours for the comet. M45 looks like it could be a quickie as the previous Hyperstar image was only 19 X 1 minute.

Messier 45 – the Pleiades
M45 s.jpg
M45 s.jpg (1.13 MiB) Viewed 965 times
22:16 – 22:52 hrs EST, 19 Jan 2023
13 X 3 min, unbinned, 200 gain, -20° cooling, 1 Hz guiding
Explore Scientific 102mm triplet with Optolong LP-P filter and ASI 2600MC-P camera

Again, I stacked and ran the initial arcsinh stretch in IP and did the rest of the processing in PS. This is noticeably better than the 2 Jan 2021 Hyperstar image run 19 X 1 min, -20C 100 gain:
M45 annotated.jpg
M45 annotated.jpg (4.17 MiB) Viewed 965 times

Friday, 20 Jan 2023

Comet C/2022 E3 ZTF is only .5 AU (48 million miles) from Earth and is reportedly very bright. With an apparent motion of 5”/minute I’m not quite sure as to what to use as exposure times. First try is 49 X 1 minute (03:38 – 04:27 hrs) The tail’s not as bright as anticipated, so 2nd try is 14 X 3 minutes (04:34 – 05:13 hrs). Let’s see how that went….
Comet 2022 E3 ZTF s.jpg
Comet 2022 E3 ZTF s.jpg (1.26 MiB) Viewed 965 times
Stacked in Deep Sky Stacker, stretched in ImagesPlus and subsequently processed in PhotoShop. ZTF’s tail is pretty faint so I’m satisfied with this image.

Conclusions & lessons learned:

The M33 images were brighter on the right hand side of the frames, and I’ve previously observed this to be a problem. While it’s possible that the computer screens were shining on the left hand side of the dome shutter it’s also possible that there’s a small light leak through the ASI filter drawer. The filter area was covered for subsequent imaging and there was no problem with M45 or with the comet.

While the Triangulum was brighter in the Hyperstar image there’s sharper detail and better color in the new refractor image.

M45 is significantly improved over the old Hyperstar version. Exposure was 39 minutes rather than 19 minutes. Vastly different scopes but improved processing skills?

Comet ZTF was discovered last March by the Zwicky Transient Facility. According to NASA, ZTF has a greenish, coma, short broad dust tail, and long faint ion tail. The greenish color associated with a molecule made from two carbon atoms bonded together, called dicarbon. Dicarbon molecules emit green light as sunlight decays them.

The very noisy live stacked frames in Sharpcap showed traces of both tails all the way up to the NW corner of the image. Had the same noise problem when stretching the image in post processing so the final image here is really a compromise.. I’ve used it before, but figuring out the DSS stacking software was a challenge this time around. Now that I’ve got it in hand I’ll be trying for the comet again only with increased exposure. It’ll be an evening object by next week and that’ll make things easier too.
Pete P.
User avatar
NGC7000
15+ Years Member
Posts: 2880
Joined: Thu Dec 21, 2006 9:51 pm

Re: M33, M45 and C/2022 E3 dusk to dawn

Unread post by NGC7000 »

As you mention, Pete, improved processing skills are demonstrated here, especially with M45. It has few rivals. M33 is nice and sharp and the refractor does seem to help with that. Loved the Comet image!

And I can't believe you found enough time to image at all in this seemingly endless stretch of grey gloom. :lol:

Tom
Tom H
"Science knows no country, because knowledge belongs to humanity, and is the torch which illuminates the world. Science is the highest personification of the nation because that nation will remain the first which carries the furthest the works of thought and intelligence." - Louis Pasteur
User avatar
menardre
Vice President
Posts: 888
Joined: Tue Jan 17, 2012 6:09 pm

Re: M33, M45 and C/2022 E3 dusk to dawn

Unread post by menardre »

Pete

Really nice work with your refractor. M33 and M45 both very well done. I agree that there is more detail than with Hyperstar. Stars are really pin-point and the details in M45 are great.

I plan on getting out as soon as the weather clears to view the new comet.

A few nights ago the sky cleared for a short time and I was able to find comet c/2020 V2 (ZTF). It was mostly a small fuzzy ball with slightly brighter central region.

Roger
Roger M.
Celestron CPC1100 EDGE, Stellarvue 130T refractor dual mounted on iOptron CEM120 on permanent pier mounted in Observatory. Imaging camera ZWO ASI2600 OSC, guide camera Lodestar or ZWO ASI290MM.
User avatar
Apollo XX
MSSF Coordinator
Posts: 2786
Joined: Sun Jul 11, 2010 8:11 pm

Re: M33, M45 and C/2022 E3 dusk to dawn

Unread post by Apollo XX »

menardre wrote: Mon Jan 23, 2023 10:20 am Pete

A few nights ago the sky cleared for a short time and I was able to find comet c/2020 V2 (ZTF). It was mostly a small fuzzy ball with slightly brighter central region.

Roger
Yes, I've seen that one visually too (I've dubbed it 'Victoria'...these modern naming conventions are dull and clinical). It is quite faint and as you say small with a slightly brighter core.

Mike M.
"The purpose of life is the investigation of the Sun, the Moon, and the heavens." - Anaxagoras
User avatar
Pete
Astro Day Coordinator
Posts: 4003
Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2003 9:03 pm

Re: M33, M45 and C/2022 E3 dusk to dawn

Unread post by Pete »

You did better than I did on the visual Mike. Even with the computerized scope finding and tracking the comet I was unable to view it through the 10X50s or the 15X70s. Perhaps that's due to the sky having lost a bit of its earlier transparency.
Pete P.
rose
Secretary
Posts: 314
Joined: Mon Aug 02, 2004 8:44 pm

Re: M33, M45 and C/2022 E3 dusk to dawn

Unread post by rose »

Nice job Pete! great pictures, Loved the comet pic! Rose
Rose A.
Meade 6" LXD55 scope on lx200 tripod with a unistar light mount
8"Meade LX200 Classic scope on a Bresser EXOS2 Goto mount
Post Reply